Butterfield's Ice Cream Menu (Updated 2026)

Welcome to Butterfield's Ice Cream, where homemade indulgence meets flavor variety. Nestled at 946 W Main St, Dover-Foxcroft, ME, this delightful ice cream parlor offers an impressive array of sundaes and classic flavors. Signature dishes like the Piscataquis Power Plus and the DoverFoxcroft Sundae showcase their commitment to quality and creativity, each crafted with care from high-quality dairy.

Customer testimonials rave about the rich textures and vibrant flavors, with standouts including banana cream pie and black raspberry. Visitors appreciate the unique offerings, from Butter Pecan to Mocha Fudge Brownie, promising something for everyone, including pup ice cream for your furry friends. While some feedback points to occasional service hiccups, the overall vibe remains warm and inviting. Experience the magic of homemade ice cream like never before at Butterfield's—your taste buds will thank you!

The menu emphasizes a variety of sundaes alongside numerous ice cream flavors, indicating a focus on customizable frozen desserts. Sundaes are priced mainly between $5.25 and $8.00, representing budget-friendly options, while the Butterfield's Special at $13.25 stands out as a premium offering. Ice cream scoops and specialty flavors are available across a moderate price range, supporting diverse preferences. The inclusion of ice cream sodas and classic sundaes suggests suitability for afternoon or evening indulgence. Overall, choices cater to both casual treats and more elaborate dessert experiences.